Defenses to Alienation of Affection in North Carolina

In a previous article we reviewed the elements of the claims for alienation of affections in North Carolina.   How is an alienation of affections case defended?

The usual defense is for a defending party to claim that there was no love and affection in existence between the husband and wife.    In other words, there can not be any alienation of affections of there were no affections to alienate.

Another defense I have seen is for the responding party to  claim that they were unaware that there was a marriage.   This defense hinges on the point that there can not be any wanton and malicious interference if the defendant did not know there was a marriage in the first place.

Statutes of limitation may also be pled as a defense in alienation of affections cases.  Statutes of limitation make certain claims stale because the plaintiff waited to long to file his or her case.

Another defense related to the timing of the events of the case, is the North Carolina statute that says: “no act of the defendant shall give rise to a cause of action for alienation of affection or criminal conversation that occurs after the plaintiff and the plaintiff’s spouse physically separate with the intent of either the plaintiff or the plaintiff’s spouse that the physical separation remain permanent.”

There are a few other defenses as well.  If you are the target of an alienation of affections claim you should consult with an attorney to review the allegations against you and discuss your options.


Scott Allen is a divorce attorney in Raleigh, NC with over twenty-three years of experience in all areas of family law litigation and settlement including matters related to alienation of affections and criminal conversation claims and defenses. He can be reached at 919.863.4183.


Representation Matters

"Scott was wonderful throughout the long process and it was clear to me that Scott was knowledgeable of case-law and the Wake County Court system, as well as being especially strong in court. His representation resulted in additional parenting time following the temporary custody trial and since the case proceeded to a full trial, I was ultimately awarded the custody arrangement I was seeking. My daughters reside in Wake County and now if my ex-wife chooses to relocate, I’ll have full legal custody of the girls. Throughout the process, Scott was responsive, provided extremely helpful advice, and genuinely cared about the outcome of my case. I would strongly recommended Scott’s representation for custody matters."

Jon H

Cared About My Situation

I was out of options and Scott was there to help. I have spoken to or met many attorney's in Wake County and Scott was the only one that REALLY actually cared about my situation. It sounds cliche' but it's not. I could clearly tell that Scott had given a lot of thought to my case. Scott has extensive knowledge of the law. That knowledge coupled with his cerebral approach and courtroom presence were a savior. - Ken

Secured My Life

"Scott Allen and his team were sensational during my divorce proceedings. They kept me well-informed of the procedures, requirements, and options. They took the time to explain to me at every step of the decisions and options as we moved forward in my life. Their support, knowledge and presence were comforting in my time of need and help me get through the ordeal. While no divorce is pleasant outcome they help me secure my life and begin a new chapter with a fresh start. Their extensive knowledge of the law and arbitration and negotiation skills were invaluable in getting a good settlement and resolution. I am very pleased that I selected Scott and his team to represent me. I would emphatically recommend Scott and to anyone who is facing a divorce or possibility of a divorce."

Steven D

Fought for My Rights

I wanted to go to court and he went with it. During the initial hearing and all the subsequent hearings he fought for my rights and presented my case diligently and proved the claims by the other party to be false. Most of the lawyers, will tell you settle as it saves them and the court time, but it might not be always in your best interest. Scott is not those lawyers, he really cares about his clients and is not afraid to litigate or fight for his client’s right in the court. - Susan

I Began to Sleep Better at Night

Scott Allen took my divorce case after my first lawyer failed to stand for my rights.Scott took the case and I began to sleep better at night. My marriage ended from abuse so I was very weary. - Felicia